STATE CAMPAIGN FOR THE CLOSURE OF CIEs AND THE END OF DEPORTATIONS
This year, on June 15, Day Against ICNs, takes place in the process of extraordinary regularization of migrants in Spain where the organized migrant community has been a fundamental asset to get this initiative underway. And it is also now during the open period for submitting applications; It continues to support their dissemination, accompanying people, informing groups and denouncing obstacles along the way, such as difficulties with the certificate of vulnerability, criminal records or the lack of collaboration of public administrations.
But during this process, the rights of people in an irregular administrative situation continue to be violated, such as racial profiling identifications in the vicinity of consulates, public registers and transport stations. Deportation devices are also continued with equal or greater frequency.
In this context, We denounce that detention in the CIE is posing a threat to the right to regularization. The current procedure does not take into account the need to facilitate access to regularisation for persons deprived of liberty and protected by the administration in EICs. We are faced with a cruel and unjust paradox: Many people who should be in the process of obtaining their residency have been deported from these centers. Mounir and Oussama's deportation attempts to Morocco from the CIE of Valencia, and Omar's from Algeciras, were able to stop and have been able to continue with the process, but we know of other cases with similar circumstances and worse luck (such as the deportation of Abdou to Senegal). We do not know how many other people in similar situations will have been detained and deported.
We condemn the difficulties in access to defence and effective judicial protection. of persons detained in the CIE, as well as of those detained for a maximum of 72 hours in police stations to execute an express deportation. The same is true of CATEs, Temporary Care Centres for Foreigners, which should fulfil the humanitarian function of caring for people rescued at sea. Access to defence becomes a genuine "legal labyrinth". The involvement of the legal profession ex officio in different procedures (detention, expulsion or others) is often disjointed, which makes it difficult for inmates to fully exercise their right to a legal defence. This situation means that, sometimes, such access is a mere procedure and that the appeals against detention do not reflect the real circumstances of rooting or the situations of vulnerability of the people affected. We also reject the existence of ‘automatic’ detentions that do not analyse each case, nor do they avoid unnecessary detentions, especially when factors such as the person’s vulnerability, their health situation or their degree of previous roots occur.
In the same way, we convey our protest about the difficulties to social organizations in their work to monitor that there are no violations of the rights of internal persons. Slow bureaucracy and access restrictions prevent effective human and legal accompaniment. The various complaints before Control Courts and before the Ombudsman's Office of different organizations and platforms show the lack of privacy in the visits, to which would be added the need for dignified spaces where there can be privacy, eliminating obstacles such as the screens that the courts themselves have ordered to remove in some CIE (such as in Valencia and Aluche). These practices, in addition to accentuating the opacity of these centers, further isolate ICNs and make them spaces beyond control and accountability.
Finally, we show our utmost concern at the implementation of the European Pact on Migration and Asylum (EPMA) and the EU Return Regulation, which directly affects ICDs, as it reinforces detention to increase deportation or forced return. We warn about the introduction of the "triage" system, which makes Spain the gendarme of "Europa Fortaleza", commercializes protection and reduces minimum guarantees for vulnerable people and minors without the company of an adult family member.
The punitive approach to migration management in the European Union and its Member States is being standardised in the purest American ICE style through policies that intensify control and detention mechanisms for persons in an irregular administrative situation, while broadening pressure to deploy more intrusive surveillance devices. In addition, there is a worrying trend towards the criminalisation of both migrants and the organisations and citizens supporting them, which violates fundamental rights such as solidarity and humanitarian assistance.
This framework increases the risk of discriminatory practices, such as disproportionate police stops in public spaces. It also legitimises strategies for outsourcing asylum management to third countries, which in many cases do not guarantee adequate standards of human rights protection. The extension of the list of “safe countries” by Europe and the admission of the possibility of setting up detention centres – called return centres – in third countries is alarming, as it extends the outsourcing of control beyond borders.
We urge the Spanish Government to maintain its current opposition to these measures, in particular to the creation of ‘return centres’ in third countries, as they violate international standards for the protection of human rights due to poor effective control of outsourced centres, limited access to legal aid, insufficient international protection and a breach of the principle of non-refoulement. We call for transparency and answers to the questions raised about detention centres built in Mauritania financed with money from the Government of Spain and the European Union Emergency Trust Fund. And we are strongly opposed to the implementation of a model of prison outsourcing in countries where human rights and human dignity are not respected.
We also reject the investment of more than €30 million in the new Algeciras macro-CIE,symbol of a failed and cruel model: While the region where it is located suffers serious deficiencies in health and social infrastructure, the State builds an "industrial scale" infrastructure aimed at repression. It is unacceptable that funds should be earmarked for a "prison for the innocent" instead of reception and inclusion policies.
For all this, from the State Campaign against the CIE and for the End of Deportations we demand:
- The release of all persons interned in CIE, CATE or detained in police stations for the execution of the expulsion or return order who may benefit from the Extraordinary Regularization, since the procedure allows the order to be revoked.
- Mechanisms to ensure that persons who have applied for regularisation are not detained or deported while their files are being processed.
- The final closure of all EIPs and opposition to the macro-centre model initiated in Algeciras
- A commitment firm of the Spanish authorities against the externalisation of borders and the establishment of detention centres in third countries.
- The end of regulations that criminalize migration and the commitment to safe and legal pathways.
Migrating is a right.
Internment and deprivation of liberty for administrative reasons are a stain on our democracy.
